Where Do I Start Reading Clayface? Three Comics for Fans of the Movie.

Where Do I Start Reading Clayface? Three Comics for Fans of the Movie.

The Clayface movie is in theaters now, and it is a full-on body horror take on the character, with Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen, an actor whose career ends in disfigurement and who takes an experimental treatment that turns his body into living clay. If you walked out of the theater wanting more, you are in luck. Clayface has been a Batman villain since 1940, and while there is no single famous run to point to, there are three books on our shelf right now that add up to a perfect starting point.

1. Clayface #1 Special Edition

Start here, and start cheap. DC released this special edition for one dollar ahead of the film, and it reprints "The Challenge of Clayface" from Detective Comics #298, the first appearance of Matt Hagen, the version of the character you just saw on screen. It also includes "If a Man Be Clay," a short story by Steve Purcell with art by Mike Mignola, and a preview of the new Clayface: Celebrity Dirt series. One dollar and about ten minutes of reading, and you have the character's foundations.

2. Batman: One Bad Day - Clayface

This is the main event, and the closest thing to required reading. Written by Collin Kelly and Jackson Lanzing with art by Xermanico, this hardcover tells the story of Basil Karlo, the original Clayface, a failed actor who takes his act to Hollywood to start his career over and becomes a killer instead. The filmmakers pulled from this book directly: there is even a movie within the movie called One Bad Day, and the plot thread about Hagen's best friend mirrors what Karlo does here. If the film's mix of Hollywood tragedy and horror worked for you, this is where it came from. It is a complete, self-contained story, so no homework is required before or after.

3. Batman Arkham: Clayface

Once you are hooked, this collection is the deep dive. It gathers standout Clayface stories from across the decades, and it is where new readers discover the character's strangest fact: there has been more than one Clayface. Karlo and Hagen are only the beginning. Reading the older stories after the first two picks shows you how each era reinvented him, from master of disguise to living clay monster to something sadder and more human.

All three are in stock now at Alter Ego Comics, in the shop and online. If you saw the movie this weekend, tell us what you thought, and we will point you to the right shelf.

Back to blog